Beyond the Nest Egg: Net Unrealized Appreciation and Its Role in Retirement Planning
Unlocking the Hidden Value in Your Company Stock for Tax-Advantaged Growth
For many executives, employer-sponsored retirement plans like 401(k)s include company stock that has appreciated significantly over time. When it’s time to retire or separate from service, one advanced planning technique—Net Unrealized Appreciation (NUA)—can unlock significant tax savings if executed properly. This whitepaper explores how NUA works, why it may be right for your retirement strategy, and how to integrate it into a comprehensive wealth plan.
1. Understanding Net Unrealized Appreciation (NUA)
Why This Matters: Net Unrealized Appreciation (NUA) is a powerful strategy that allows retirees to convert the tax on appreciated company stock held inside a 401(k) or similar plan into long-term capital gains instead of ordinary income, under specific conditions. The tax differential between ordinary income and capital gains can be significant—especially for those in the highest tax brackets.
Key Points:
- NUA Defined: The difference between the cost basis (what you paid for the stock) and its current market value at distribution.
- Tax Treatment: You pay ordinary income tax only on the cost basis at the time of distribution. The NUA at distribution is taxed at long-term capital gains rates when the stock is ultimately sold.
- Qualified Distribution Event Required: NUA is only available after a triggering event such as separation from service, turning age 59½, disability, or death.
Sample Scenario: A retiring executive holds $1.2 million of company stock in their 401(k) with a cost basis of $300,000. By electing an NUA distribution, they pay ordinary income tax on the $300,000 but defer capital gains tax on the remaining $900,000. When the stock is sold, they pay long-term capital gains tax—resulting in potential six-figure tax savings compared to traditional IRA withdrawals.
Key Takeaways:
- NUA converts ordinary income tax into capital gains tax for eligible company stock.
- Timing and execution are critical to maintaining tax benefits.
- Only employer stock qualifies—other securities do not.
2. Identifying When an NUA Strategy May Be Right for You
Why This Matters: Not every retirement scenario benefits from an NUA strategy. Understanding your cost basis, retirement timeline, and overall income picture helps determine if it’s a fit. In the right situation, NUA can be one of the most tax-efficient ways to reduce concentrated stock positions.
Considerations for NUA Suitability:
- Low Cost Basis, High Appreciation: The greater the unrealized appreciation, the greater the benefit.
- Upcoming Retirement or Job Change: Triggering events create the opportunity for NUA—but the window is limited.
- Desire for Immediate Liquidity: Selling NUA stock can generate cash with favorable tax treatment.
- High Income Tax Bracket: NUA can be a way to manage income in retirement by reducing reliance on traditional IRA distributions.
Sample Scenario: A 61-year-old tech executive plans to retire within the year. Their company stock inside their 401(k) has increased tenfold over 20 years. After consulting their advisor, CPA, and estate attorney, they use an NUA strategy for a portion of their stock while rolling the remaining balance into an IRA. This tailored approach helps minimize the overall tax impact of the appreciated stock while keeping their long-term income needs intact.
Key Takeaways:
- Best suited for individuals with highly appreciated company stock.
- May provide tax efficient short-term liquidity.
- Proper timing is crucial; one misstep (like rolling to an IRA) can eliminate the benefit.
- Use in conjunction with other retirement income strategies for optimal flexibility.
3. Avoiding Common Mistakes with NUA Distributions
Why This Matters: Even though NUA is straightforward in concept, it’s easy to make costly mistakes during implementation. Some missteps can permanently disqualify you from taking advantage of this strategy.
Potential Pitfalls to Watch For:
- Rolling Employer Stock into an IRA: Doing so forfeits NUA eligibility permanently.
- Ineligible Distributions: Partial distributions from the employer plan or failing to take a lump-sum distribution in the correct tax year can void the NUA opportunity.
- Neglecting RMD Rules: If you’re age 73 or older, required minimum distributions (RMDs) may complicate timing.
- Ignoring the overall tax impact: For employees under age 55 or otherwise ineligible for an exclusion, the 10% penalty will still apply to distributions of employer stock. In addition, AMT may reduce the tax benefits if applicable.
- Failing to model the long term – Executing the strategy without modeling the tax implications over the long term can actually increase your overall tax liability.
Sample Scenario: A recently retired executive rolls over their entire 401(k), including company stock, into an IRA. Months later, they learn about NUA—but it’s too late. Because the stock is no longer in the 401(k), the opportunity is lost, and all withdrawals from the IRA will be taxed as ordinary income.
Key Takeaways:
- NUA is a one-time opportunity—attention to detail is essential.
- Coordinate early with a tax professional before any distribution occurs.
- Have a sell strategy in place to manage concentration and market risk.
4. Integrating NUA Into Broader Retirement and Estate Planning
Why This Matters: NUA should be one piece of your overall retirement plan—not a standalone move. It complements other strategies like Roth conversions, charitable giving, and multi-generational estate planning.
Strategies for Integration:
- Roth Conversion Timing: After NUA stock is moved, the rest of the 401(k) can be rolled into an IRA and strategically converted to a Roth over time.
- Charitable Giving: Donating appreciated NUA stock to a Donor-Advised Fund (DAF) or other charitable vehicle can avoid capital gains tax and provide a deduction.
- Trust and Estate Planning: NUA stock may not receive a step-up in basis upon death. Consider using trusts to help manage this and preserve generational value.
Sample Scenario: A high-net-worth retiree implements an NUA strategy on $700,000 of company stock, then donates a portion to a DAF in a high-income year. They also set up a Charitable Remainder Trust to provide income while passing remaining assets to a favorite charity—aligning retirement income, tax reduction, and legacy goals.
Key Takeaways:
- Consider how NUA fits with your philanthropic and generational goals.
- Trust structures can provide continued control and tax advantages.
- A comprehensive plan ensures NUA isn’t working in isolation.
5. The Importance of Working With a Multi-Disciplinary Advisory Team
Why This Matters: Because of the tax rules, deadlines, and estate planning implications, NUA is a strategy that requires a coordinated team effort. Working with your financial advisor, CPA, and estate attorney ensures all the moving parts align.
Why a Team Approach Helps:
- Tax Timing and Reporting: Your CPA can ensure correct reporting on required IRS Forms.
- Retirement Income Modeling: Your financial advisor can structure income needs and withdrawal plans based on your broader goals.
- Estate Strategy Alignment: Your attorney can integrate NUA decisions into trusts, legacy planning, and beneficiary designations.
Sample Scenario: A second-generation family business owner retires and initiates an NUA strategy on a portion of their retirement plan. Their advisory team coordinates the timing of a lump-sum distribution, sells shares gradually over time, and places the proceeds into trust vehicles aligned with their long-term legacy goals.
Key Takeaways:
- A team-based approach ensures alignment across tax, investment, and estate strategies.
- Don’t make NUA decisions in isolation—each component impacts the others.
- Success with NUA relies on professional oversight and proactive planning.
Conclusion
For those with highly appreciated company stock inside retirement plans, Net Unrealized Appreciation is more than a tax opportunity—it’s a bridge between liquidity, tax-efficiency, and long-term planning. When timed and executed correctly, NUA can unlock meaningful financial flexibility while supporting estate and philanthropic goals.
Overall Key Takeaways:
- NUA allows you to pay capital gains tax instead of ordinary income tax on appreciated employer stock.
- Timing, qualification rules, and distribution procedures are critical.
- NUA works best when integrated with a broader plan for retirement income, charitable giving, and wealth transfer.
- Collaborating with a trusted team of professionals ensures the strategy is implemented without costly mistakes.
If you would like more information about the terms and strategies discussed in this guide, or if you’re ready to explore how they apply to your specific situation, contact Waverly Advisors. With experience working with individuals, families, and executives managing significant wealth, we specialize in creating tailored strategies with the goal to help you grow, protect, and transfer your assets effectively.
IMPORTANT DISCLOSURES
THE INFORMATION PRESENTED IN THIS DOCUMENT IS FOR GENERAL INFORMATIONAL AND EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES, AND IS NOT SPECIFIC TO ANY INDIVIDUAL’S PERSONAL CIRCUMSTANCES. NOTHING IN THIS DOCUMENT CONSTITUTES, OR SHALL BE RELIED UPON AS INVESTMENT, LEGAL, OR TAX ADVICE TO ANY PERSON. THE INFORMATION IN THIS DOCUMENT IS PROVIDED EFFECTIVE AS OF THE DATE OF ITS PUBLICATION, DOES NOT NECESSARILY REFLECT THE MOST CURRENT STATUS OR DEVELOPMENT, AND IS SUBJECT TO REVISION AT ANY TIME. INVESTING INVOLVES RISK, AND PAST PERFORMANCE DOES NOT NECESSARILY PREDICT FUTURE RESULTS. NONE OF WAVERLY, OR ANY OF ITS OFFICERS, MEMBERS OR AFFILIATES, IN ANY WAY WARRANT OR GUARANTEE THE SUCCESS OF ANY ACTION THAT ANYONE MAY TAKE IN RELIANCE ON ANY STATEMENTS OR RECOMMENDATIONS IN THIS DOCUMENT.
WAVERLY ADVISORS, LLC (“WAVERLY”) IS AN SEC-REGISTERED INVESTMENT ADVISER. A COPY OF WAVERLY’S CURRENT WRITTEN DISCLOSURE BROCHURE AND FORM CRS (CUSTOMER RELATIONSHIP SUMMARY) DISCUSSING OUR ADVISORY SERVICES AND FEES REMAINS AVAILABLE AT HTTPS://WAVERLY-ADVISORS.COM/. YOU SHOULD NOT ASSUME THAT ANY INFORMATION PROVIDED SERVES AS THE RECEIPT OF, OR AS A SUBSTITUTE FOR, PERSONALIZED INVESTMENT ADVICE FROM WAVERLY ADVISORS, LLC (“WAVERLY”). THIS INFORMATION SHOULD BE USED AS A REFERENCE ONLY. TALK TO YOUR WAVERLY ADVISOR, OR A PROFESSIONAL ADVISOR OF YOUR CHOOSING, FOR GUIDANCE SPECIFIC TO YOUR SITUATION. PLEASE NOTE: THE SCOPE OF THE SERVICES TO BE PROVIDED DEPENDS UPON THE NEEDS OF THE CLIENT AND THE TERMS OF THE ENGAGEMENT.
INVESTMENT ADVISORY SERVICES ARE OFFERED BY WAVERLY ADVISORS, LLC, AN INVESTMENT ADVISER REGISTERED WITH THE SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION. © 2024 WAVERLY ADVISORS, LLC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.